Where the Costco Anywhere Visa beats Citi Double Cash, and where it falls behind
For a Costco member, the Costco card earns 120 dollars a year more on fuel and dining in Julia's worked example; Citi Double Cash earns more on everything else.

The short answer
If your family keeps Costco anyway, the Costco Anywhere Visa belongs on Costco, fuel and dining, and Citi Double Cash belongs on everything else. In Julia's worked example that split returns 516 dollars a year, 120 more than the same year earns at a flat 2 percent.
The Costco Anywhere Visa wins at the pump and at the restaurant table. In Julia's example it pays 5 percent on Costco gas, 4 percent on other eligible fuel and 3 percent on dining. Citi Double Cash pays 2 percent on purchases paid under its rules. At Costco itself the Costco card's 2 percent only ties a 2 percent card, and Double Cash, a Mastercard, can't be used inside Costco warehouses. On ordinary purchases the Costco card earns 1 percent and Double Cash earns 2.
The membership decides the rest. If you'd join Costco mainly for the card, the 65 dollar Gold Star membership cuts the 120 dollar lead to 55. Julia's Wallet Score counts that membership for everyone. It puts Citi Double Cash at 69 and the Costco Anywhere Visa at 56.
Side by side
Costco Anywhere Visa by Citi, terms checked October 6, 2026:
- Annual fee: none beyond an active, paid Costco membership. Standard Gold Star membership costs 65 dollars a year plus applicable tax.
- Costco and Costco.com: 2 percent.
- Eligible gas and electric-vehicle charging: 4 percent. Julia's worked examples count Costco gas at 5 percent. The gas rates share a 7,000 dollar yearly limit, after which fuel earns 1 percent.
- Restaurants and eligible travel: 3 percent.
- Everything else: 1 percent.
- Rewards: one certificate a year, issued after the February statement closes. You redeem it for cash or merchandise at U.S. Costco warehouses, including Puerto Rico, by its deadline.
- Foreign transaction fee: none.
- Julia's Wallet Score: 56 out of 100.
Citi Double Cash, terms checked October 6, 2026:
- Annual fee: none, and no membership needed.
- Purchases: 2 percent. You earn 1 percent when you buy and 1 percent through eligible payments, provided you meet the minimum payment requirement. Paying in full earns both.
- Costco warehouses: Double Cash can't be used inside, because it is a Mastercard.
- Rewards: ThankYou points worth 1 cent each as an eligible statement credit or direct deposit.
- Foreign purchase fee: 3 percent.
- Balance transfers: an introductory 0 percent offer for 18 months from account opening, on transfers made in the first 4 months. Fees can apply.
- Julia's Wallet Score: 69 out of 100.
Where each one wins
The Costco Anywhere Visa wins at the pump. In Julia's worked example, a family buys 3,600 dollars of fuel: 2,400 at Costco pumps and 1,200 elsewhere. That fuel earns 168 dollars on the Costco card. At a flat 2 percent, the rate Citi Double Cash pays, the same fill-ups earn 72. The Costco card comes out 96 dollars ahead.
The Costco Anywhere Visa also wins on dining and eligible travel, at 3 percent. On the family's 2,400 dollars of eligible dining it earns 72 dollars, against 48 at 2 percent, which is 24 more. That card suits existing Costco members who buy fuel and eat out.
Citi Double Cash wins on ordinary purchases. On the family's 9,000 dollars of everything else, Double Cash earns 180 dollars and the Costco card earns 90. Double Cash points also redeem as cash at 1 cent each. The Costco card's reward arrives as one certificate a year, so it can't help with this month's bill.
At Costco, the Costco Anywhere Visa carries the purchases at no loss. Its 2 percent ties a 2 percent card, and Citi Double Cash can't be used inside the warehouse.
On trips, the Costco Anywhere Visa charges no foreign transaction fee. Citi Double Cash charges a 3 percent foreign purchase fee. An 800 dollar purchase abroad earns 16 dollars on Double Cash and costs 24 in fees, which leaves you 8 dollars behind.
A higher rate can still lose to a lower price. Julia's pump example compares two fill-ups of the same quantity and grade:
- At the Costco card's pump, 70 dollars with 5 percent back costs 66.50 dollars after rewards.
- At another pump, 65 dollars with 2 percent back costs 63.70.
The cheaper pump wins by 2.80 dollars.
The arithmetic
Julia's worked example follows one family's 19,800 dollar year in five lines. Each line shows what the Costco Anywhere Visa earns and what a flat 2 percent earns:
- Costco and Costco.com, 4,800 dollars: 96 at 2 percent on the Costco card, and 96 at a flat 2 percent.
- Costco gas, 2,400 dollars: 120 at 5 percent, against 48 at 2 percent.
- Other qualifying fuel, 1,200 dollars: 48 at 4 percent, against 24 at 2 percent.
- Eligible dining, 2,400 dollars: 72 at 3 percent, against 48 at 2 percent.
- Everything else, 9,000 dollars: 90 at 1 percent, against 180 at 2 percent.
The Costco card's figures add up to 426 dollars. The 2 percent figures add up to 396. Julia measures against a no-fee 2 percent Visa, which can also pay at Costco. Citi Double Cash earns the same 2 percent on paid purchases where it is accepted, but not inside Costco warehouses.
Three ways to divide the year:
- A flat 2 percent card on everything: 396 dollars.
- The Costco Anywhere Visa on everything: 426 dollars, 30 more.
- The Costco Anywhere Visa on Costco, fuel and dining, plus Citi Double Cash on everything else: 516 dollars. The Costco card earns 96 plus 120 plus 48 plus 72, or 336 dollars, and Double Cash earns 180.
The split earns 120 dollars more than the flat 2 percent card, which is the fuel and dining lead. It earns 90 more than the Costco card alone, because Double Cash earns 180 on the ordinary purchases where the Costco card earns 90. No purchase changes, only the card used at each checkout. In the split, the Costco card's 336 dollars arrive as that single certificate after February.
The 7,000 dollar gas limit matters for heavy drivers. In Julia's heavy-driving year, all 8,000 dollars of fuel is Costco gas, and 5 percent would suggest 400 dollars. The first 7,000 earn 350, and the last 1,000 earn 10 at 1 percent. The Costco Anywhere Visa returns 360 in all. Once the limit is used up, another card may earn more on the next fill-up.
Every figure here assumes purchases are paid without borrowing costs, so no interest comes out of the rewards.
Does the $65 Costco membership change the answer?
The Costco Anywhere Visa has no separate annual fee while you hold an active, paid Costco membership. Citi Double Cash needs no membership.
- If your family would keep Costco anyway, count the membership at zero. The Costco card doesn't add that cost, and the 120 dollar fuel and dining lead stands.
- If you'd join mainly for the Costco card, count the membership in full. 120 minus 65 leaves 55 dollars, before membership tax or anything the membership saves you in the aisles.
- If you'd join for the Costco card and also use it for everything, start from the 30 dollar edge (426 against 396). Minus 65, that leaves you 35 dollars behind a flat 2 percent.
So an existing member and someone joining for the card can reasonably choose differently.
Executive members might count 4 percent at Costco. The 2 percent Executive reward belongs to the membership, which is a separate program. If you'd keep that membership either way, the reward counts on both sides. The Costco Anywhere Visa itself adds 2 percent at the warehouse, the same as another 2 percent card.
What do Julia's Wallet Scores of 69 and 56 measure?
Julia's Wallet Score rates each card out of 100 on her everyday card test. Most of the weight goes to value after costs across three household budgets. Reward flexibility, effort and two protections follow.
The Costco Anywhere Visa scores 56. Fuel and dining help it. Two things hold it back: the full ordinary membership cost and the wait for an annual certificate. Julia's test charges the membership even to a family that already pays for Costco, so every card starts from the same point.
Citi Double Cash scores 69. The cash is easy to use, and there is no bonus category to manage. Double Cash gives up a little because Julia's standard shopping basket includes some spending inside Costco, where a Mastercard can't be used.
The scores compare the two cards on equal terms, with the membership included. If your family already wants Costco, Julia weighs two things: the extra dollars from the Costco card itself, 120 a year in her worked example, and whether waiting for the certificate bothers you.
Before you apply
On Citi's page for the Costco Anywhere Visa, look at:
- The gas rates and the shared 7,000 dollar limit. Julia's worked examples use 5 percent for Costco gas, and the terms checked October 6, 2026 list 4 percent on eligible gas. Confirm the Costco gas rate before counting on it.
- Which purchases count as restaurants and eligible travel.
- When the certificate is issued, where it can be redeemed and its deadline.
- The current Gold Star membership price and tax.
On Citi's page for Citi Double Cash, look at:
- How the payment portion is earned, and the minimum payment requirement. A rewards statement credit isn't a payment and doesn't replace the minimum due.
- The 3 percent foreign purchase fee.
- The balance-transfer window, length and fee, if you'd move debt. The offer doesn't automatically cover new purchases.
Treat any welcome bonus as a separate first-year extra, and use the offer actually available to you.
Terms checked October 6, 2026. Rates, fees and offers may have moved since.
The cards in this guide
Keep reading
- Which cash back card setup earns the most for a family budget, and when it's worth it
- Which Credit Cards Earn the Most on Gas, and What the Fine Print Means
- Which cash back card pays a big family the most on groceries once the fee is out
- Which credit cards earn the most at restaurants, ranked by Julia's Wallet Score
Terms checked Oct 6, 2026. Not financial advice.