Julia’s WalletIndependent credit card testsSubscribe
Tech · 6 min read · Updated Nov 17, 2026

Apple Card or PayPal Cashback Mastercard: which earns more on your online orders

On $6,000 of online orders, PayPal checkout with the PayPal Cashback Mastercard earns $180 and Apple Pay with Apple Card earns $120; the checkout button decides it.

Apple Card or PayPal Cashback Mastercard: which earns more on your online orders

The short answer

On online orders, the PayPal Cashback Mastercard earns more when you pay through PayPal checkout and choose the card there: 3% against 2% for Apple Card through Apple Pay. On $500 a month of online orders, $6,000 a year, that is $180 on the PayPal Cashback Mastercard and $120 on Apple Card, a $60 difference.

Both cards lose most of their edge when you type the card number into a store's checkout. The PayPal Cashback Mastercard then earns 1.5%, and Apple Card earns 1%. Neither card charges an annual fee, so the habit you bring to checkout matters more than either card's headline rate.

On Julia's everyday card test, Apple Card scores 65 out of 100 and the PayPal Cashback Mastercard scores 62 out of 100. Terms checked October 6, 2026.

Side by side

Apple Card:

  • Annual fee: none.
  • 3% Daily Cash on Apple purchases and qualifying partners.
  • 2% on purchases made with Apple Pay.
  • 1% on other purchases generally, including the physical card and the card number typed into a checkout.
  • No late, foreign-transaction or over-limit fees.
  • Wallet Score: 65 out of 100, assuming 75% of eligible spending goes through Apple Pay.

PayPal Cashback Mastercard:

  • Annual fee: none. Issued by Synchrony Bank.
  • 3% on eligible online purchases made through your PayPal account when you choose this card to pay.
  • 1.5% on other eligible purchases, including the card number typed into a store's checkout.
  • A 3% foreign transaction fee, including qualifying transactions outside the United States charged in dollars.
  • A $1.99 monthly paper statement fee when a paper statement is sent and the balance exceeds $2.50. Electronic statements avoid it.
  • Wallet Score: 62 out of 100, assuming eligible PayPal checkout handles half of online shopping.

Both cards pay cash back, with no point values to estimate. Terms checked October 6, 2026.

Which checkout habit does each card need?

Apple Card needs the Apple Pay button. A $100 purchase earns $2 in Daily Cash through Apple Pay but $1 with the physical card or the card number. On an online order, Apple Card earns the 2% rate only where the store offers Apple Pay at checkout and you use it.

The PayPal Cashback Mastercard needs the PayPal button and the right choice inside it. In Julia's worked example, a $240 desk chair earns $3.60 at 1.5% when the card number is typed into the store's checkout. The same chair paid by selecting PayPal, signing in and choosing the PayPal Cashback Mastercard earns $7.20. Seeing the PayPal button does not tell you which payment method is selected. Julia would check that this card is chosen, not a bank account, PayPal balance or another saved card.

The PayPal Cashback Mastercard added to a different mobile wallet does not get the PayPal rate. An ordinary tap that way generally earns 1.5%. An authorized user cannot add their card to their own PayPal account, so their eligible purchases generally earn 1.5%.

Apple Card's 3% applies to Apple purchases and qualifying partners. Partners have their own payment and booking requirements, so a partner's name alone is not enough.

Where each one wins

The PayPal Cashback Mastercard wins on orders from stores that accept PayPal, paid through PayPal checkout with this card selected. Each $100 moved there from a 2% card earns 1 extra dollar. Julia's one-line fit for the card is "PayPal checkout purchases, especially as a second card."

Apple Card wins where a store offers Apple Pay but not PayPal: 2% against 1.5% for the PayPal Cashback Mastercard paid by card number. Apple Card also wins on Apple purchases at 3%, and on spending abroad, since it charges no foreign-transaction fee. Julia's one-line fit for Apple Card is "An existing Apple Pay routine."

Neither card does well as the only card for a household with many bills that take only a card number. Those earn 1% on Apple Card and 1.5% on the PayPal Cashback Mastercard, both below a flat 2% card.

The arithmetic

The online mix. Take Julia's $500 a month of online orders, $6,000 a year, and assume every order can go through either button:

  • PayPal Cashback Mastercard through PayPal checkout: 3% of $6,000 is $180.
  • Apple Card through Apple Pay: 2% of $6,000 is $120.
  • Apple Card by typed card number: 1% of $6,000 is $60.

The PayPal Cashback Mastercard through PayPal checkout leads Apple Pay by $180 minus $120, which is $60.

Apple Card on a whole budget. In Julia's first budget, $9,000 goes through Apple Pay, $1,500 is eligible Apple purchases and $3,000 goes on the card number or physical card, $13,500 in all. Apple Card earns $180, $45 and $30, so $255. A flat 2% card earns $270 on the same $13,500, leaving Apple Card $15 behind. Moving $2,000 of the 1% spending to Apple Pay adds $20, taking Apple Card to $275, $5 ahead of the flat card. Against a 2% card, each dollar at 3% adds 1 cent, each dollar at 1% gives up 1 cent, and Apple Pay ties.

The PayPal Cashback Mastercard on a whole budget. Julia adds $12,000 of purchases that do not qualify for the PayPal rate to the $6,000 of online orders. At 1.5%, the $12,000 earns $180, so the PayPal Cashback Mastercard returns $180 plus $180, $360 on $18,000. A flat 2% card also returns $360. Keeping the flat card for the $12,000 and using the PayPal Cashback Mastercard only for qualifying orders earns $420 between them, the same $60 improvement. If only $4,000 of the $18,000 goes through eligible PayPal checkout, the PayPal Cashback Mastercard alone earns $330 against $360, $30 behind. As the only card, more than a third of spending has to earn 3% to beat a flat 2% card.

Price comes first. In Julia's worked example, the $240 chair costs $232.80 after 3% back through PayPal checkout. The same chair at $225 from another trustworthy store costs $220.50 after 2%, so the lower price saves $12.30. Julia would not pay $15 more for a higher percentage.

What else costs money on each card?

Apple Card charges no annual, late, foreign-transaction or over-limit fees, but interest can still apply. Apple Card's payment screen estimates interest as you change the amount you plan to pay. For Apple Card Monthly Installments, you must choose the plan at checkout for an eligible purchase; paying normally does not give you a 0% plan, and taxes and shipping are charged at the regular purchase rate.

The PayPal Cashback Mastercard's paper statement fee, if it applied in all 12 months, would cost $23.88, a noticeable piece of the $60 gain. The 3% foreign transaction fee could undo the PayPal Cashback Mastercard's rewards on purchases abroad. Moving rewards into PayPal is not the same as paying the card bill, and returns can reduce the rewards.

For both cards, Julia would pay the full statement balance. Paying interest to earn an extra 1% would not help a shopping budget.

Before you apply

Sort a month of your online orders into three groups: stores that accept PayPal, stores that offer Apple Pay, and stores that take only a card number. Estimate the year from purchases you would make anyway.

On Apple's page, confirm the 3%, 2% and 1% Apple Card rates, the partner requirements and the installment terms. On the issuer's page for the PayPal Cashback Mastercard, confirm the 3% and 1.5% rates, the paper statement fee, the foreign transaction fee and the rules for authorized users. Julia's Wallet Scores assume an Apple Pay share for Apple Card and a PayPal checkout share for the PayPal Cashback Mastercard; your own shares change the value. Terms checked October 6, 2026, and they may have moved since.

The cards in this guide

Keep reading

Terms checked Oct 6, 2026. Not financial advice.

New card tests every weekJulia tests these cards on camera, with the arithmetic on screen. Subscribe for the next one.Subscribe on YouTube