What five cards earn, cost and cover on a $1,200 laptop bought online
Active Cash and Double Cash each earn $24 in cash on a $1,200 laptop; Best Buy's $60 in certificates pulls ahead only if it replaces shopping you had planned.

The short answer
On a $1,200 laptop paid in full, Wells Fargo Active Cash and Citi Double Cash each earn $24 in cash at 2 percent at any store that takes the card. They also lead Julia's Wallet Score, at 70 and 69 out of 100. The My Best Buy Credit Card can show $60 on the same price, but in Best Buy certificates. Those certificates beat the $24 in cash only when at least $24 of them replaces shopping you would do anyway.
Apple Card earns $36 at 3 percent on a $1,200 Mac bought from Apple. The PayPal Cashback Mastercard earns $36 at 3 percent when the laptop goes through PayPal checkout with that card selected. Away from those two checkouts, both cards earn less than a 2 percent card.
None of the five cards earns protection points in Julia's damaged-purchase test. For a laptop, cover depends on each card's own benefit guide. The selling price still matters before any reward does. In Julia's camera-bundle example, a lower price at another store beat Best Buy's full certificate value by $13.
How do the five cards rank on Julia's Wallet Score?
Julia's Wallet Score rates each card out of 100 on her everyday card test. The test weighs value after costs across 3 households' spending first. It then looks at reward flexibility, effort and 2 protection examples. The five cards, from 70 down to 34:
- Wells Fargo Active Cash, 70: steady 2 percent cash back with no categories to follow and no annual fee.
- Citi Double Cash, 69: 2 percent in two halves, 1 percent when you buy and 1 percent through eligible payments.
- Apple Card, 65: Julia's test assumes 75 percent of spending goes through Apple Pay. A larger or smaller share changes the value.
- PayPal Cashback Mastercard, 62: Julia's test assumes half of online shopping goes through eligible PayPal checkout, which works out to a blended 2.25 percent online.
- My Best Buy Credit Card, 34: this is the no-fee, store-only version. Julia's test treats it as the main card, so purchases at other merchants earn nothing.
The score describes a year of everyday spending. A single laptop purchase can rank the cards differently, so the next section works through the one purchase.
What does each card earn on a $1,200 laptop?
Each line below uses the same inputs: a $1,200 laptop, paid in full, on a card version with no annual fee.
- Wells Fargo Active Cash: 2 percent of $1,200 is $24.
- Citi Double Cash: 1 percent when you buy ($12) plus 1 percent through an eligible payment ($12) is $24. The second half needs the eligible payment. Redeeming rewards as a statement credit does not count as that payment.
- Apple Card: bought from Apple at 3 percent, $36. Paid through Apple Pay at another store at 2 percent, $24. Paid by typing the card number at 1 percent, $12.
- PayPal Cashback Mastercard: through PayPal checkout with this card chosen inside PayPal, 3 percent, or $36. With the card number typed into the store's own checkout, 1.5 percent, or $18. Seeing the PayPal button does not tell you which payment method is selected inside it.
- My Best Buy Credit Card: at Best Buy on Standard Credit, 2.5 points per dollar gives 3,000 points. At 250 points per $5 certificate, that is $60 of certificate value, equal to 5 percent. Points have no cash value.
Is Best Buy's $60 in certificates worth more than $24 in cash?
Julia asks one question about the My Best Buy Credit Card: would at least $24 of the reward replace something you would buy anyway? That $24 is the cash you give up by not using a 2 percent card.
- If all $60 replaces a planned purchase at a competitive price, you finish $36 ahead of the cash card ($60 minus $24).
- If the certificates replace only $20 of shopping you would do anyway, the $24 in cash is better.
My Best Buy Credit Card certificates typically expire 60 days after they are issued. They give no cash change and cannot pay the card bill. Active cardmembers can choose point banking instead of immediate certificates, subject to the program rules.
Compare prices before rewards. In Julia's camera-bundle example, the same $1,200 bundle cost $1,150 at another store with equivalent shipping and returns. With 2 percent back, it cost $1,127 there. At Best Buy, $1,200 minus a fully used $60 certificate leaves $1,140. Buying elsewhere saves $13.
Three more My Best Buy Credit Card figures (terms checked October 6, 2026):
- A Plus or Total membership adds 1 percent, or $12 on $1,200. You get that $12 whichever card you pay with at Best Buy, so it adds nothing to the case for this card.
- The current new-card offer adds another 5 percent in points on qualifying Standard Credit purchases on the first purchase day within 14 days of opening. That would bring the $1,200 bundle to $120 of certificates. It applies once and does not repeat each year.
- Versions of the card carry annual fees from $0 to $59. With the $59 fee, the $60 reward on this purchase falls to $1, well below the $24 in cash.
Should you pay for the laptop over time?
The My Best Buy Credit Card's current storewide offer is 12 months on qualifying purchases of at least $299 (terms checked October 6, 2026). It is deferred interest: if the purchase is not paid in full within the period, interest applies from the purchase date. Promotional financing earns no Standard Credit points, so you give up the $60. If you also have an eligible membership, you give up $72 in all, $60 from the card and $12 from the membership. Ten payments of $120 would clear $1,200 before the deadline, with proper allocation. The minimum payment could be lower and might not finish the balance in time.
Wells Fargo Active Cash currently offers 12 months at 0 percent on purchases from account opening (terms checked October 6, 2026). In Julia's worked example, a $1,200 purchase made at the start is cleared early with 10 payments of $120.
Apple Card Monthly Installments must be chosen at checkout for an eligible purchase. In Julia's example, a $1,200 Mac over 12 months costs $100 a month and earns $36 in Daily Cash. The full $1,200 uses your available credit, and taxes and shipping are charged at the regular purchase rate. If the same Mac costs $1,100 at a reputable retailer with comparable condition, warranty and returns, that price is $64 below Apple's $1,164 after Daily Cash.
Citi Double Cash's introductory offer is for balance transfers. It does not automatically cover new purchases.
Which card protects a laptop if it breaks?
Julia's protection test uses two fixed examples: an eligible purchase damaged after 30 days, and a trip canceled for a covered illness. Five cards: Active Cash, Double Cash, Apple Card, the PayPal Cashback Mastercard and the My Best Buy Credit Card. None of the five earns protection points there. That result does not mean every account lacks coverage, but it does mean none of these cards stands out for laptop cover on the score. Wells Fargo Active Cash's phone protection applies when the monthly wireless bill is paid with the card; it covers a phone, not a laptop.
Julia's method is to start with what went wrong:
- Accidental damage points to purchase protection, which generally covers specified events during a set period after purchase.
- A part that fails points to the original warranty first, then any extended warranty.
- A laptop you simply don't want points to the store's return policy.
Save the itemized receipt, the proof of card payment and the warranty. Weigh rewards against cover that actually fits the purchase. On a $650 purchase, an extra 1 percentage point in rewards is $6.50. Never add a coverage maximum to your rewards as if you will receive it. With the PayPal Cashback Mastercard, a return can also reduce the rewards earned.
Before you act
- Wells Fargo Active Cash: check the 2 percent rate, the 12-month 0 percent purchase offer and the welcome offer on your own application.
- Citi Double Cash: check the eligible-payment rule that earns the second 1 percent.
- Apple Card: check the 3, 2 and 1 percent rates and whether your laptop is eligible for Monthly Installments.
- PayPal Cashback Mastercard: check the 3 and 1.5 percent rates, and confirm the card is selected inside PayPal before you pay.
- My Best Buy Credit Card: check the exact version and its annual fee, the financing terms, the certificate expiry and the opening offer's first-purchase-day rule.
For all five cards, read the benefit guide before you rely on any laptop cover. Compare the laptop's price across stores before comparing rewards.
Terms checked October 6, 2026. Rates, fees and offers may have moved since, so confirm them on each issuer's page.
The cards in this guide
Keep reading
- When Apple Pay earns more rewards, and when a flat 2 percent card still wins
- Which card earns what when you buy Apple products and pay with Apple Pay
- What your credit card can cover when your phone breaks, goes missing or is stolen
- When a bill-category card beats flat cash back on internet and TV bills
Terms checked Oct 6, 2026. Not financial advice.