Julia’s WalletIndependent credit card testsSubscribe
Points & Miles · 6 min read · Updated Nov 16, 2026

Amex Gold or Amex Green: which card pays for food habits and which pays for travel

Gold earns 4 points on restaurants and U.S. supermarkets for a 325 dollar fee; Green earns 3 on travel, transit and restaurants for 150. Your spending decides.

Amex Gold or Amex Green: which card pays for food habits and which pays for travel

The short answer

If your spending leans toward food, Amex Gold earns more usable points. Amex Gold pays 4 points per dollar at restaurants and U.S. supermarkets, while the Amex Green Card pays 3 at restaurants. If your spending leans toward trains, parking and hotel stays, Amex Green pays 3 points per dollar on travel and transit too. Amex Green's annual fee is 150 dollars and Amex Gold's is 325 dollars (terms checked October 6, 2026).

Neither card wins on points alone. In Julia's worked examples, each card trails a no-annual-fee card when its points are worth 1 cent or less. Each pulls ahead only with one particular habit. For Amex Gold, that habit is a travel award worth 1.5 cents a point. For Amex Green, it is a CLEAR Plus membership you already pay for.

Julia's Wallet Score gives Amex Gold 67 and Amex Green 52, both out of 100. The gap comes from which habits each card pays for. Amex Gold rewards food spending that most households already have. Amex Green needs enough travel and transit spending to carry its fee past ordinary 1-point purchases.

Side by side

Amex Gold:

  • Annual fee: 325 dollars
  • 4 points per dollar at restaurants worldwide, on up to 50,000 dollars a calendar year
  • 4 points per dollar at U.S. supermarkets, on up to 25,000 dollars a calendar year
  • 3 points per dollar on eligible flights booked directly or through Amex Travel
  • 5 points per dollar on prepaid Amex Travel hotels, and 2 on eligible prepaid car rentals and cruises there
  • 1 point per dollar on other purchases, and on spending past either limit
  • Credits: up to 10 dollars a month in dining credit at participating partners, 10 dollars a month in Uber Cash, up to 7 dollars a month at Dunkin', and up to 50 dollars at Resy in each half of the calendar year
  • Wallet Score: 67

Amex Green:

  • Annual fee: 150 dollars
  • 3 points per dollar on eligible travel, transit and restaurant purchases
  • 1 point per dollar on other eligible purchases
  • Up to 219 dollars in statement credits each calendar year for a qualifying CLEAR Plus membership charged to the card account
  • Wallet Score: 52

Amex Green's travel category covers flights and hotels. It also covers eligible vacation rentals, cruises and campgrounds. Its transit category covers trains, rideshares, tolls, parking, buses and subways. You do not have to book through Amex Travel to earn the travel rate.

With Amex Gold, the store's classification matters. Warehouse clubs and superstores do not count as U.S. supermarkets, even when you buy groceries there.

With Amex Green, a restaurant inside another business may not earn restaurant points. A meal charged to a hotel room can also be treated differently from paying the restaurant directly.

Amex now calls the existing card the Classic Green Card. As of October 2026, its old application page leads to Amex's general card page.

Do Amex Gold's credits cover the 325 dollar fee?

Amex Gold's dining, Uber Cash, Resy and Dunkin' credits add up to a headline 424 dollars a year. That is not one pot of money. Each credit has its own rules, enrollment and deadline, and a missed month does not roll over. Additional cards share the account's allowance rather than adding to it.

In Julia's video on Amex Gold, she counts only the credits that replace meals already in her budget:

  • 8 dining credits of 10 dollars each: 80 dollars
  • both 50 dollar Resy allowances: 100 dollars
  • Uber Cash and Dunkin': 0, because she would not use them in her normal routine

That makes 180 dollars of useful credits. If you miss both Resy allowances, take 100 dollars off every Amex Gold result below. Higher delivery prices can also eat into a credit, and a new dinner bought to use a credit is still a new expense.

Is Amex Green worth 150 dollars without CLEAR?

Amex Green's CLEAR Plus credit counts only if it replaces a membership you were already going to buy. There is one allowance per card account, so adding family members does not multiply it. If another card already covers your membership, you cannot count the same saving again on Amex Green. The membership also renews automatically unless you cancel it.

Julia's test gives CLEAR no assumed value, and that is part of why Amex Green scores 52. If you would not pay for CLEAR Plus on your own, Amex Green has to win on its points alone.

The arithmetic

These are two separate worked examples, each on its own card's budget. Do not subtract one result from the other.

Amex Gold on a food budget. The budget is 6,000 dollars at U.S. supermarkets plus 4,800 dollars at restaurants, or 10,800 dollars in all. At 4 points per dollar, that earns 43,200 points. The 180 dollars of credits are added and the 325 dollar fee is subtracted. The comparison is a no-annual-fee card earning 3 percent on the same purchases, such as Capital One Savor, which would pay 324 dollars.

  • Points used to cover card charges at 0.6 cent: 259.20 + 180 − 325 = 114.20 dollars, which is 209.80 dollars behind Savor
  • Points used on an eligible Amex Travel flight at 1 cent: 432 + 180 − 325 = 287 dollars, which is 37 dollars behind Savor
  • Points used on an available transfer award worth 1.5 cents: 648 + 180 − 325 = 503 dollars, which is 179 dollars ahead of Savor

Amex Green on a travel budget. The budget is 4,800 dollars of travel, 2,400 dollars of transit and 4,800 dollars of restaurants, or 12,000 dollars in all. At 3 points per dollar, that earns 36,000 points. The comparison is Wells Fargo Autograph, a no-annual-fee card that earns 3 points per dollar on the same categories. Autograph's points would pay 360 dollars as cash at 1 cent each.

  • Points used on an eligible Amex Travel flight at 1 cent: 360 − 150 = 210 dollars, which is 150 dollars behind Autograph
  • The same, plus 219 dollars of CLEAR Plus you already pay for: 210 + 219 = 429 dollars, which is 69 dollars ahead of Autograph
  • Points used to cover card charges at 0.6 cent: 216 − 150 = 66 dollars before any CLEAR credit, well behind Autograph

The same spending can land ahead or behind depending on how the points are used. Covering charges on the bill is the weakest choice for both Amex Gold and Amex Green.

Where each one wins

Amex Gold fits someone whose spending is mostly restaurants and U.S. supermarkets. It also fits someone who uses the dining and Resy credits on meals they already buy. Amex Gold comes out ahead in Julia's example only with a booked award worth more than 1 cent a point. At 1 cent, it is still 37 dollars behind a 3 percent food card. Amex Gold is a poor match if you want simple cash back.

Amex Green fits someone whose year runs through train platforms, parking, rideshares, cabins and ordinary hotels, and who already pays for CLEAR Plus. Without CLEAR, Amex Green is 150 dollars behind Wells Fargo Autograph at 1 cent a point. A transfer award could change that, but only with a real booking.

For either card, transfers are final. Find the available award first, confirm the transfer ratio, and subtract taxes and fees from the cash price the points replace.

Why does Amex Gold score 67 and Amex Green 52?

Julia's Wallet Score is built from four parts:

  • 55 points for value after costs across 3 household budgets
  • 20 points for using rewards
  • 15 points for effort
  • 10 points for 2 specific protections

Both scores value points through a fixed 1 cent flight booking, so a single impressive transfer cannot raise either result.

Amex Gold reaches 67 because it fits more of the food spending in those household budgets. That result depends on actually using the card's restricted credits.

Amex Green stops at 52 because its broad travel categories help, but its fee and its ordinary 1-point purchases hold it back. CLEAR adds no assumed value in the test.

Before you apply

On the issuer's page, confirm:

  • Whether Amex Green, now the Classic Green Card, is open to new applicants, or ask Amex which options your account actually has
  • That your grocery stores code as U.S. supermarkets for Amex Gold
  • The enrollment steps and monthly or half-year timing of each Amex Gold credit
  • Whether CLEAR Plus serves your usual airports before you count Amex Green's credit
  • Today's transfer ratios and award availability before moving any points
  • What happens to your existing Membership Rewards points if you change or close an account

Terms checked October 6, 2026. Fees, earning rates and credits may have moved since then, so confirm the current terms on the issuer's page.

The cards in this guide

Keep reading

Terms checked Oct 6, 2026. Not financial advice.

New card tests every weekJulia tests these cards on camera, with the arithmetic on screen. Subscribe for the next one.Subscribe on YouTube