Julia’s WalletIndependent credit card testsSubscribe
Credit Cards · 7 min read · Updated Nov 6, 2026

How Citi Double Cash and Citi Custom Cash compare, and when carrying both pays more

Custom Cash wins on one category up to $500 a cycle, Double Cash on the rest; carrying both earned $660 a year in Julia's example, $180 more than Double Cash alone.

How Citi Double Cash and Citi Custom Cash compare, and when carrying both pays more

The short answer

Citi Custom Cash earns more on one steady category, up to $500 a billing cycle. On $500 of groceries in a cycle, Custom Cash earns $25 and Citi Double Cash earns $10. Past that $500, Custom Cash pays 1 percent and Double Cash pays 2 percent. That is why carrying both earns the most in Julia's household example: $660 a year, against $480 on Double Cash alone.

That answer is for people who already hold Custom Cash. Citi closed new applications for Custom Cash on May 28, 2026, and says existing cardholders are unaffected. If you are opening a new account, Double Cash is the one of the two that takes applications.

Julia's Wallet Score gives Double Cash 69 out of 100 and Custom Cash 63. The score asks each card to carry a whole household's spending. Custom Cash is worth more as a partner to Double Cash, with one limited job, than its score suggests.

Side by side

Terms checked October 6, 2026.

  • Annual fee: Citi Double Cash charges $0. Citi Custom Cash charges $0.
  • Double Cash earning: 2 percent on purchases, with no category to manage. You earn 1 percent when you buy and 1 percent through eligible payments, provided you meet the minimum payment. Paying in full earns both halves.
  • Custom Cash earning: 5 percent on the first $500 in your highest-spending eligible category each billing cycle, then 1 percent on everything else. Over 12 cycles that comes to at most $6,000 of spending at 5 percent. Room left unused in one cycle does not carry into the next.
  • Custom Cash categories: restaurants, gas stations, grocery stores, drugstores, select travel, select transit, select streaming services, home improvement stores, fitness clubs and live entertainment. Citi picks the top category automatically, and there is nothing to activate each quarter.
  • Double Cash rewards: ThankYou points, worth 1 cent each through eligible statement-credit or direct-deposit cash redemptions.
  • Custom Cash rewards: ThankYou points, worth 1 cent each through cash redemption.
  • Applications: Double Cash takes them. Citi closed new applications for Custom Cash on May 28, 2026.

How much does the $500 cap cut Custom Cash's lead over Double Cash?

These figures cover one category in one billing cycle, all on one card, against the same spending on Double Cash:

  • $500: Custom Cash earns $25. Double Cash earns $10.
  • $1,000: Custom Cash earns $30, which is $25 on the first $500 plus $5 on the next $500, an effective 3 percent. Double Cash earns $20.
  • $1,500: Custom Cash earns $35, which is $25 on the first $500 plus $10 on the other $1,000. Double Cash earns $30.

Custom Cash leads by $15 at $500 and by $5 at $1,500. The lead stops growing at the cap, because each dollar past $500 earns 1 cent on Custom Cash and 2 cents on Double Cash.

The same limit applies to a large grocery bill. On a $1,200 grocery cycle, Custom Cash earns $32, not the $60 that 5 percent on the whole bill would suggest. That $32 is $25 on the first $500 plus $7 on the other $700.

The Custom Cash allowance resets each billing cycle, and a cycle does not always start on the first of the month. Julia's uneven-year example has $200 of qualifying spending in each of 6 cycles and $800 in each of the other 6, which adds up to $6,000.

  • The quiet cycles earn $10 each.
  • The busy cycles earn $28 each, which is $25 plus $3.
  • The year comes to $228.

The same $6,000 spread evenly at $500 a cycle earns $300 on Custom Cash, so the uneven year earns $72 less. Double Cash earns $120 on that $6,000 either way. Custom Cash stays ahead, but its unused room in quiet cycles cannot roll into a busy one.

The arithmetic

Julia's household example spends $2,000 a month, or $24,000 a year of eligible purchases, with every bill paid in full.

  • Double Cash alone: 48,000 points, or $480 at 1 cent each.
  • Both cards: Custom Cash takes exactly $500 of one category each cycle and earns $25 a cycle for 12 cycles, or $300 for the year. Double Cash takes the other $1,500 a month at 2 percent and earns $360 for the year. Together they earn $660.

Carrying both earns $180 more than Double Cash alone. Julia's grocery example shows the same $180: $500 of groceries every cycle earns $300 on Custom Cash against $120 on a 2 percent card. The second card adds only the difference between 5 percent and 2 percent on that first $500. Double Cash earns the $360 on everything else in either setup.

On Custom Cash alone, every purchase past the first $500 in its top category would earn 1 percent instead of 2. That is why the pair earns more than either card by itself.

The $660 assumes three things:

  • exactly $500 of qualifying spending every cycle
  • purchases that fit Citi's category rules
  • no interest

The uneven year above shows what happens to the Custom Cash share when spending is uneven.

Where each one wins

Citi Double Cash fits:

  • A household's mixed spending, with no category to manage. Groceries and gas earn the ordinary 2 percent without having to fit a special category.
  • Everything past Custom Cash's first $500 in a cycle, and every purchase outside Custom Cash's top category. On those purchases Double Cash pays 2 percent and Custom Cash pays 1.
  • A new account. In the public offer as of October 2026, Double Cash has a limited introductory 0 percent balance-transfer offer. Qualifying transfers get 18 months from account opening if you complete them within the first 4 months, and fees can apply. Julia keeps that repayment job separate from everyday spending.

Citi Custom Cash fits one steady eligible expense close to $500 a cycle, such as groceries or gas, with Double Cash taking the rest.

Custom Cash's automatic choice follows your biggest eligible category, not the job you meant for the card. Julia's home-improvement example puts $400 of groceries and a $600 eligible home-improvement purchase on Custom Cash in the same cycle. Home improvement takes the top spot:

  • Home improvement earns $25 on its first $500 and $1 on the other $100.
  • The groceries earn $4 at 1 percent.
  • The total is $30.

Now put the home-improvement purchase on a 2 percent card such as Double Cash instead. The groceries earn $20 on Custom Cash and the home improvement earns $12 on the other card, for $32.

Citi picks your largest eligible category, but it does not work out the best mix across your cards. If your family shares the Custom Cash account, agree together on what the card is for.

Why does Double Cash score 69 and Custom Cash 63?

Julia's Wallet Score puts most of its weight on value after costs across three household budgets. Reward flexibility, effort and protection make up the rest.

Double Cash scores 69 out of 100. Its cash is easy to use, and there is no bonus category to manage.

Custom Cash scores 63. Automatic category selection helps, but the $500 cap per billing cycle, followed by 1 percent, holds the card back when it has to cover a whole household's spending. The Custom Cash score is a rating for existing cardholders.

The 6-point gap answers a different question from pairing. For a pair, Julia asks what the second card adds on just the purchases you would move. She also asks whether your family will remember which card to use. A lower-scoring card can still be the better partner if it fills a gap, as Custom Cash does in the household example. Her rule is one card, one job, one sentence. For this pair, the sentence is: Custom Cash takes one category up to $500 a cycle, and Double Cash takes everything else.

Before you apply

  • Citi closed new applications for Custom Cash. If you hold one, the closure does not mean your account is closing or your rewards are gone. It also does not guarantee an upgrade, so read any notice about your own account.
  • On your latest Custom Cash statement, look for three things: which category won, how much went over $500, and what earned only 1 percent.
  • Use your actual billing cycles. A purchase near the statement closing date can land in a different cycle.
  • Do not spend more to fill the allowance. Another $100 of purchases at 5 percent earns $5 and still costs you $95.
  • On Citi's page for Double Cash, confirm how the 2 percent splits between purchases and payments, the cash redemption value, and the balance-transfer dates and fee.
  • A statement-credit redemption does not count as a payment, so it does not replace the minimum payment due.
  • Treat any Double Cash welcome bonus as a separate first-year extra. A bonus does not change the ongoing rate.
  • Look up the foreign purchase fee on each card before using it abroad.
  • Every figure here assumes purchases are paid in full, without interest.

Terms checked October 6, 2026. Card terms can change and may have moved since then. The issuer's page for each card shows the current version.

The cards in this guide

Keep reading

Terms checked Oct 6, 2026. Not financial advice.

New card tests every weekJulia tests these cards on camera, with the arithmetic on screen. Subscribe for the next one.Subscribe on YouTube