Costco Anywhere Visa or Sam's Club Mastercard: what each card adds to the same spending
The club decides it: Costco's card ties a 2 percent card at Costco, while Sam's card pays Plus members 3 percent and Club members 1 percent at Sam's.

The short answer
On the same fuel and dining, the Costco Anywhere Visa and the Sam's Club Mastercard pay back the same: 120 dollars on 2,400 dollars of fuel at 5 percent, and 72 dollars on 2,400 dollars of dining at 3 percent. The club decides the rest. The Costco card earns 2 percent at Costco. The Sam's Club card earns 3 percent at Sam's Club for Plus members and 1 percent for Club members.
The Costco Anywhere Visa's 5 percent applies to Costco gas; other eligible gas earns 4 percent. Against a flat 2 percent card, with ordinary purchases kept on that card, the Costco Anywhere Visa puts an existing member 120 dollars a year ahead in Julia's Costco example. That example uses 4,800 dollars at the warehouse, 3,600 of fuel (2,400 of it Costco gas) and 2,400 of dining.
The Sam's Club Mastercard puts an existing Plus member 144 dollars ahead in her Sam's Club example. That example uses 5,400 at the club, 2,400 of fuel and 1,800 of dining. The two budgets differ, so each total belongs to its own card.
Neither card charges a separate annual fee, but each needs its own club. Costco Gold Star costs 65 dollars a year; Sam's Club costs 60 dollars for Club and 120 for Plus. The membership you would keep anyway usually picks the card. Julia's Wallet Scores are 56 for the Costco Anywhere Visa and 55 for the Sam's Club Mastercard.
Side by side
Terms checked October 6, 2026.
The Costco Anywhere Visa by Citi:
- 2 percent at Costco and on Costco.com
- 5 percent on eligible Costco gas and 4 percent on other eligible gas and electric-vehicle charging, sharing a limit of 7,000 dollars a year, then 1 percent
- 3 percent at restaurants and on eligible travel, 1 percent on everything else
- No separate annual fee with an active, paid Costco membership
- Rewards generally paid once a year as a certificate after the February statement closes, redeemable for cash or merchandise at U.S. Costco warehouses, including Puerto Rico
The Sam's Club Mastercard:
- 3 percent on eligible Sam's Club purchases for Plus members, 1 percent for Club members
- 5 percent on eligible gas and electric-vehicle charging on the first 6,000 dollars combined each calendar year, then 1 percent
- 3 percent on eligible dining, 1 percent on everything else
- No separate annual fee, with a Sam's Club membership required
- Rewards paid as Sam's Cash, generally within 1 or 2 billing cycles, for club purchases or cash through the club's process
The Costco Anywhere Visa certificate cannot help with this month's bill. The Sam's Club Mastercard's Sam's Cash comes sooner, though Sam's Cash is not an instant discount or a bank deposit.
Where each one wins
The Costco Anywhere Visa fits a household that already pays for Costco and spends on Costco gas and dining, with ordinary purchases on a 2 percent card. That household comes out 120 dollars a year ahead in Julia's Costco example. The Costco card also has the higher fuel limit, 7,000 dollars against 6,000, and the 8,000 dollar year below shows the difference. At the warehouse, the Costco Anywhere Visa only ties a 2 percent card.
The Sam's Club Mastercard fits two kinds of member:
- A Plus member, who earns 1 percentage point more at the club than on a 2 percent card
- Any member buying fuel and dining, since the fuel rate does not need Plus
The Plus household comes out 144 dollars a year ahead in Julia's Sam's Club example. At other eligible pumps, the Sam's Club Mastercard pays 5 percent where the Costco card pays 4, up to the 6,000 dollar limit. At the club, a Club member earns 1 percent on the Sam's Club Mastercard, half what a 2 percent card pays.
If a second account makes tracking harder, one card for everything is the simpler choice, at a smaller gain.
The arithmetic
Julia's Costco example is for a household already paying for Costco. It compares the Costco Anywhere Visa with the no-fee Fidelity Rewards Visa at 2 percent:
- 4,800 dollars at the warehouse: 96 on both cards
- 3,600 dollars of fuel, 2,400 of it Costco gas and 1,200 elsewhere: 120 plus 48 makes 168 on the Costco Anywhere Visa, against 72, so 96 ahead
- 2,400 dollars of dining: 72 against 48, so 24 ahead
- 9,000 dollars of everything else: 90 against 180
With the Costco Anywhere Visa used for everything, the 19,800 dollar year returns 426 dollars against 396, only 30 ahead. Now put the first three lines on the Costco card (336 dollars) and the 9,000 on the 2 percent card (180). The pair earns 516, a 120 dollar lead.
Julia's Sam's Club example is for a household already paying for Plus. It compares the Sam's Club Mastercard with a 2 percent card:
- 5,400 dollars at the club: 162 from the Sam's Club Mastercard plus 108 from the Plus reward makes 270. The 2 percent card earns 108 plus the same 108, or 216, so the Mastercard is 54 ahead
- 2,400 dollars of fuel: 120 against 48, so 72 ahead
- 1,800 dollars of dining: 54 against 36, so 18 ahead
- 9,600 dollars of everything else: 96 against 192
With the Sam's Club Mastercard used for everything, the 19,200 dollar year returns 540 against 492, 48 ahead. With ordinary purchases moved to the 2 percent card, the pair earns 636. That keeps the full 144 dollar gain: 54 plus 72 plus 18.
Now run the same household as Club members. The Sam's Club Mastercard's 1 percent earns 54 dollars on the 5,400, against 108 on the flat card. The 90 dollar fuel-and-dining gain, 72 plus 18, covers that 54 dollar shortfall and leaves 36 ahead before ordinary purchases. Paying at the club with the 2 percent card keeps the full 90.
In a year of 8,000 dollars of fuel, the two limits give different results:
- Costco Anywhere Visa, all Costco gas: 350 on the first 7,000 and 10 on the last 1,000 at 1 percent, 360 in all
- Sam's Club Mastercard, all qualifying fuel: 300 on the first 6,000 and 20 on the last 2,000, 320 in all, an effective 4 percent. That last 2,000 would earn 40 on a 2 percent card
The pump price can outweigh either card's 5 percent. A 70 dollar fill-up with 5 percent back costs 66.50 dollars after rewards. The same quantity and grade at 65 dollars with 2 percent back costs 63.70, so the cheaper pump wins by 2.80. Every sum here assumes you pay in full, with no interest.
Which membership does each card need?
The Costco Anywhere Visa needs an active, paid Costco membership. Gold Star costs 65 dollars a year plus tax (terms checked October 6, 2026). A household keeping Costco anyway counts that cost at zero, and the 120 dollar lead in Julia's Costco example stands.
If you would join mainly for the Costco card, take the 65 from the 120 and 55 dollars is left, before tax. If you join and also use the card for everything, the 30 dollar edge less 65 leaves you 35 dollars behind. An Executive member's 2 percent reward comes with that membership and counts on both sides, so the Costco Anywhere Visa does not add it.
The Sam's Club Mastercard needs a Sam's Club membership: 60 dollars for Club or 120 for Plus (terms checked October 6, 2026). The fuel rate does not require Plus. The 2 percent Plus reward also counts on both sides. That reward has its own exclusions and limit, so not every purchase, online order or fuel stop earns both layers.
Upgrading from Club to Plus costs another 60 dollars. Compare Club with a 2 percent card against Plus with the Sam's Club Mastercard. The second setup earns 3 percentage points more on purchases that qualify for both programs, which covers the 60 at 2,000 dollars of spending. That move changes the membership and the card at once, so it does not show what Plus alone is worth. If you would join or upgrade because of the Sam's Club Mastercard, count that cost against the gain.
What do the Wallet Scores of 56 and 55 assume?
Both scores come from Julia's everyday card test, out of 100. The test gives the most weight to value after costs, measured across three household budgets. Reward flexibility, effort and two protections follow.
The Costco Anywhere Visa's 56 charges the full ordinary Costco membership, even for a household that already pays for it, so every card starts from the same point. Fuel and dining help the score. The membership cost and the wait for a yearly certificate hold the score back.
The Sam's Club Mastercard's 55 charges the basic Club membership rather than assuming Plus. Fuel and dining help the score, and ordinary spending earns less.
If you already keep one of the clubs, the extra dollars in Julia's worked examples fit your situation more closely than either score.
Before you apply
On Citi's page for the Costco Anywhere Visa, confirm:
- the gas, charging and restaurant rates
- the 7,000 dollar shared limit
- when the certificate arrives and its redemption deadline
- the Gold Star price
On the issuer's page for the Sam's Club Mastercard, confirm:
- the Plus and Club rates at the club, and the dining rate
- the 6,000 dollar fuel limit
- when Sam's Cash posts
- the Club and Plus prices, and the exclusions and limit on the Plus reward
Then run your own year through both cards: fuel at each kind of pump, dining, club shopping and everything else. Terms checked October 6, 2026; rates, limits and prices can change after that date.
The cards in this guide
Keep reading
- Which Credit Cards Earn the Most on Gas, and What the Fine Print Means
- Where the Costco Anywhere Visa beats Citi Double Cash, and where it falls behind
- Credit card cash advances: the fee, the interest and why the due date does not help
- Credit card interest builds daily, so pay the statement balance and confirm your payoff
Terms checked Oct 6, 2026. Not financial advice.