Julia’s WalletIndependent credit card testsSubscribe
Credit Cards · 7 min read · Updated Nov 16, 2026

When Bank of America Unlimited Cash Rewards beats Citi Double Cash, and when it doesn't

At its own 1.5 percent, Unlimited Cash Rewards earns $120 less than Double Cash on $24,000 a year; it pulls ahead only from the Preferred Honors tier up.

When Bank of America Unlimited Cash Rewards beats Citi Double Cash, and when it doesn't

The short answer

Without a Bank of America relationship bonus, Citi Double Cash returns more. In Julia's worked example of $24,000 of yearly purchases, Double Cash earns $480 at 2 percent and Bank of America Unlimited Cash Rewards earns $360 at 1.5 percent, a $120 gap.

Bank of America Unlimited Cash Rewards moves ahead only if you already qualify for Preferred Honors or a higher tier. At Preferred Honors the card earns 2.25 percent. That is $540 on the same $24,000, or $60 more than Double Cash. The gain is worth having only if the bank accounts suit you anyway.

Both cards charge no annual fee and pay cash back. Julia's Wallet Score is 69 out of 100 for Citi Double Cash and 62 out of 100 for Bank of America Unlimited Cash Rewards.

Side by side

Terms checked October 6, 2026.

Bank of America Unlimited Cash Rewards:

  • Annual fee: $0
  • Card-only rate: 1.5 percent on purchases
  • With BofA Rewards tiers: 1.65 percent (Member), 1.87 percent (Preferred Plus), 2.25 percent (Preferred Honors), 2.62 percent (Premier)
  • Redemption: each $1 of rewards is worth $1 through an eligible cash redemption
  • Julia's Wallet Score: 62

Citi Double Cash:

  • Annual fee: $0
  • Rate: 1 percent when you buy and another 1 percent through eligible payments, 2 percent in total
  • Redemption: points are worth 1 cent each through eligible statement-credit or direct-deposit cash redemptions
  • Julia's Wallet Score: 69

The full 2 percent on Citi Double Cash assumes you pay off your purchase balances. A statement-credit redemption does not count as a payment, so the rewards cannot stand in for the minimum payment due. Earning "when you pay" means eligible payments on purchases, not paying interest. You can pay in full and still earn both halves.

How do the Bank of America tiers change the rate?

The Bank of America tiers are a percentage bonus on top of the card's 1.5 percent. They do not add percentage points. The entry Member tier has no qualifying-balance minimum and adds a 10 percent bonus. That takes Bank of America Unlimited Cash Rewards to 1.65 percent, not up by 10 percentage points.

The higher tiers depend on qualifying balances at Bank of America or Merrill:

  • Preferred Plus: from $30,000, a 25 percent bonus, 1.87 percent on the card
  • Preferred Honors: from $100,000, a 50 percent bonus, 2.25 percent on the card
  • Premier: from $1,000,000, a 75 percent bonus, 2.62 percent on the card

Qualifying takes more than a balance. For Preferred Honors you also need an eligible personal checking account, enrollment, and continued qualification under the bank's measurement rules. Holding a balance for 1 day may not be enough.

If you joined the earlier Preferred Rewards program before May 26, 2026, your Bank of America Unlimited Cash Rewards card may have an extended transition benefit. The rate shown in your own account matters more than any chart.

The arithmetic

Julia's worked example uses one household spending $2,000 a month. That is $24,000 of eligible purchases a year, all paid in full.

  • Citi Double Cash: 24,000 purchase points plus 24,000 payment points makes 48,000 points, worth $480 at 1 cent each.
  • Bank of America Unlimited Cash Rewards, card only: 1.5 percent of $24,000 is $360. Double Cash leads by $120.
  • Bank of America Unlimited Cash Rewards, Member tier: the 10 percent bonus adds $36 to the $360. Double Cash still leads by $84.
  • Bank of America Unlimited Cash Rewards, Preferred Plus: 1.87 percent is still below the 2 percent on Double Cash, so Double Cash still leads.
  • Bank of America Unlimited Cash Rewards, Preferred Honors: 2.25 percent of $24,000 is $540. Bank of America leads by $60 against the $480 on Double Cash.

The same 2 percent works out on a single purchase. On a $1,000 appliance paid off on time, Citi Double Cash earns 1,000 points at purchase and 1,000 more through the payment. That is $20.

Is moving money for Preferred Honors worth it?

In Julia's worked example, no. The card's lead is too small to pay for a weaker home for your savings. Suppose moving $100,000 to reach Preferred Honors meant earning 0.5 percentage points less interest. That costs $500 a year. The $60 that Bank of America Unlimited Cash Rewards gains over Double Cash does not come close to covering it.

Julia's view is that the banking relationship should suit your plans first. If you already hold suitable accounts or investments at Bank of America or Merrill, the higher rate on Bank of America Unlimited Cash Rewards is a welcome addition. If you would move money only for the card, compare the whole banking decision.

Rerun the sum at the rate you would earn if your balance fell. Suppose you might need part of those savings for a house. The lower-tier result then tells you whether you would still want Bank of America Unlimited Cash Rewards after you drop below the threshold.

Where each one wins

Citi Double Cash fits these people:

  • People with no Bank of America relationship, or one below Preferred Honors. On $24,000 a year Double Cash earns $120 more than Bank of America Unlimited Cash Rewards at 1.5 percent and $84 more at the Member tier.
  • People who want one flat rate with no category to manage. Groceries and gas earn the ordinary 2 percent on Double Cash without becoming a special category.
  • People who want a fallback card next to a category card. In Julia's worked example, a card earning 5 percent on $500 a month earns $300 a year. Double Cash earns $360 on the remaining $1,500 a month. Together they make $660, which is $180 more than the $480 from Double Cash alone.

Bank of America Unlimited Cash Rewards fits these people:

  • People who already qualify for Preferred Honors or Premier through accounts they want to keep. At Preferred Honors the card earns $540 on $24,000, against $480 on Double Cash.
  • People pairing it with Customized Cash Rewards at the same tier. With a 50 percent bonus on both cards, the chosen category earns 4.5 percent within its shared quarterly cap. In Julia's worked example, $8,000 of category spending on Customized Cash Rewards earns $360. The other $16,000 on Unlimited Cash Rewards, at 2.25 percent, also earns $360. That is $720 in total, against $540 with all $24,000 on Unlimited Cash Rewards alone.

The gap shrinks when other cards take most of your spending. If only $4,000 a year is left for a flat-rate card, going from the 2 percent on Citi Double Cash to the 2.25 percent on Bank of America Unlimited Cash Rewards adds $10. And if a card you already hold earns 2 percent, Citi Double Cash adds nothing to that rate.

Do welcome offers or intro rates change the answer?

Treat a welcome offer as a first-year extra, separate from the ongoing rate. Terms checked October 6, 2026: the public offer on Bank of America Unlimited Cash Rewards was $250 after $1,000 of purchases in the first 90 days. At the base rate on $24,000, that makes $610 in the first year: $360 plus $250.

Some Bank of America applications instead pay 2 percent for the first year, then 1.5 percent. If that temporary rate comes with the same $250 bonus, the first-year total is $730: $480 plus $250. Check which combination your application actually offers. Do not multiply a temporary rate by a relationship bonus unless the terms allow it.

For Citi Double Cash, use whatever welcome offer is open to you when you apply. A bonus does not raise the ongoing rate on Double Cash.

Both cards have introductory 0 percent periods:

  • Bank of America Unlimited Cash Rewards offers one on purchases and qualifying balance transfers, with deadlines and transfer fees.
  • Citi Double Cash gives qualifying balance transfers 18 months from account opening. The transfers must be completed within the first 4 months, and fees can apply. The promotion does not automatically cover new purchases, and a transferred balance earns no cash back.

On Bank of America Unlimited Cash Rewards, transfers, cash advances, interest and fees are not a way to generate rewards. On either card, count rewards only on purchases you would make anyway and pay off without interest.

Before you apply

On Bank of America's page and in your account, check these:

  • The BofA Rewards tier and the rate your account actually shows
  • The welcome offer and whether it comes with a first-year rate
  • The intro 0 percent period, its deadline and the transfer fee

On Citi's page, check these:

  • The purchase and payment earning rules
  • The cash redemption options
  • The balance-transfer window, the fee and the welcome offer currently available

Then look at your own statement. List the purchases that would move from 1.5 percent to 2 percent or more. Leave out anything that carries an extra fee, and anything that already earns a better rate on a card you hold.

Terms checked October 6, 2026. Rates, tiers and offers may have moved since, so the issuer's page is the final word.

The cards in this guide

Keep reading

Terms checked Oct 6, 2026. Not financial advice.

New card tests every weekJulia tests these cards on camera, with the arithmetic on screen. Subscribe for the next one.Subscribe on YouTube