Julia’s WalletIndependent credit card testsSubscribe
Credit Cards · 7 min read · Updated Nov 17, 2026

How Chase Freedom Rise and Discover it Secured compare as a first credit-building card

Freedom Rise scores 95 in Julia's credit-building test against 85 for Discover it Secured, mainly because Rise asks for no deposit and has a documented upgrade review.

How Chase Freedom Rise and Discover it Secured compare as a first credit-building card

The short answer

On Julia's credit-building Wallet Score, Chase Freedom Rise ranks ahead of Discover it Secured Cash Back, 95 out of 100 against 85. The main reason is the deposit: Freedom Rise asks for none, while Discover it Secured holds a refundable deposit of $49, $99 or $200. Neither card charges an annual fee (terms checked October 6, 2026).

The real question is which card you can get. Freedom Rise is unsecured, so you have to qualify without a deposit, and being a student or new to credit does not make approval certain. Discover it Secured is built for people who need a deposit to start. Discover says a credit score is not required to apply, but approval is still not automatic.

At a small budget the rewards are close. Julia's worked example for each card uses $40 of planned purchases a month:

  • Freedom Rise earns $7.20 a year at 1.5 percent.
  • Discover it Secured earns $9.60 if $120 of that spending lands in an activated 5 percent category, or $4.80 if none does.

Neither Wallet Score is a chance of approval. On either card, paying each statement in full matters more than the reward.

Side by side

Annual fee:

  • Chase Freedom Rise: none.
  • Discover it Secured: none.

Deposit:

  • Chase Freedom Rise: no security deposit.
  • Discover it Secured: a refundable deposit of $49, $99 or $200, depending on creditworthiness. The starting credit line is at least $200. You have 35 days after approval to fund the deposit, and you can pay it in installments.

Cash back:

  • Chase Freedom Rise: 1.5 percent on purchases. The current application also adds 3 percent on eligible restaurant purchases for the first 6 months, on up to $6,000 of spending.
  • Discover it Secured: 5 percent in changing quarterly categories once you activate them, up to the quarterly maximum, and 1 percent on other eligible purchases.

First-year extra:

  • Chase Freedom Rise: a $25 statement credit for automatic payments. You enroll within the first 3 months, stay enrolled for at least 90 consecutive days, and the account meets the offer conditions when the credit arrives.
  • Discover it Secured: Cashback Match. Qualifying rewards from the first 365 days after approval are matched and added within 2 billing periods afterward.

The way forward:

  • Chase Freedom Rise: Chase reviews eligible accounts each year for a first Freedom Unlimited card.
  • Discover it Secured: after a positive payment history, the account can become unsecured and the deposit returned. The current terms give no fixed timetable for this.

Julia's Wallet Score:

  • Chase Freedom Rise: 95 out of 100.
  • Discover it Secured: 85 out of 100.

Is the Discover it Secured deposit a cost?

The Discover it Secured deposit is not a fee, and Julia does not subtract it as one. It is refundable money held for the account. It can come back if the account becomes unsecured, or if you close the account and pay the balance in full. It does, however, tie up cash, and it earns no interest while Discover holds it.

In Julia's worked example, the approval comes with a $99 deposit and a $200 credit limit. The deposit does not pay the bill. If you buy $40 of household supplies, you owe that $40 separately, just as you would on Freedom Rise. Julia's first question is whether you could set the $99 aside comfortably. If that money would be needed for groceries next week, she would wait. For the Wallet Score she uses a $200 deposit, because the lower amounts depend on approval.

Chase Freedom Rise ties up nothing, but it has its own banking detail. Chase says at least $250 combined in eligible Chase checking or savings accounts can improve some applicants' chances. This applies only to people who have never had a credit card, including as an authorized user. The accounts must be open before you apply, and the funds must be available within the stated 4-day window. The balance is not required, does not ensure approval, and is not a security deposit. Fees you could not avoid on a new bank account would cut into the advantage of a card with no annual fee.

Where each one wins

Chase Freedom Rise wins on the measures Julia's test rewards most:

  • No annual fee and no security deposit.
  • A documented annual upgrade review with conditions you can work toward.

Julia's test gives Freedom Rise no points for a soft-inquiry preview, because none has been established for this exact card. The upgrade also depends on meeting every condition.

Discover it Secured wins in other ways:

  • It is the realistic option if you cannot qualify for an unsecured card.
  • Discover reports the account to the 3 major credit bureaus.
  • You can get the deposit back without closing the account.
  • Cashback Match doubles qualifying first-year rewards.

Its score is held back by the deposit and by the lack of a scheduled review. Julia does not assume an automatic review on any particular schedule. Older descriptions of this card mentioned a 7-month review, but that promise is not part of the current terms.

Julia's verdict follows from this. If you can get Freedom Rise without extra banking costs, its 95 reflects a real advantage. If a secured card is what is open to you, Discover it Secured is a strong starting option, as long as you can leave the deposit alone while paying your normal bills.

What does the path from first statement to upgrade review look like?

On Chase Freedom Rise, Julia's path starts with one planned $40 monthly bill:

  • Set up autopay within the first 3 months.
  • Check whether you chose the full statement balance or the minimum. Minimum autopay is a backup, not the same as paying in full.
  • Check the withdrawal date and leave enough in checking.
  • Confirm the first payment posted, then stay enrolled for 90 consecutive days to earn the $25 credit.
  • Each year, Chase reviews the account for a first Freedom Unlimited card. The conditions include keeping the account open, making a purchase within the previous 12 months, and satisfactory payment status with Chase and other lenders. If you have or had Freedom Unlimited, this automatic path is not available.

On Discover it Secured, Julia's path starts with the deposit:

  • Fund the deposit within 35 days by bank-account transfer. Without the full deposit, the account cannot open.
  • Make one $40 purchase already in your budget, and keep that $40 in the bank.
  • Pay the full statement balance by the due date, which avoids interest on purchases while the grace period applies.
  • Activate the quarterly categories only for purchases you had planned anyway.
  • After the first 365 days, expect Cashback Match within 2 billing periods. Do not count on it to pay an earlier bill.
  • On accounts managed by Capital One, rewards applied to the balance do not count toward the minimum payment.

With a positive history, the account can move to unsecured, but there is no graduation month to plan around.

The arithmetic

On the same $40 a month, a full year is $480 of purchases on either card.

  • Chase Freedom Rise: $480 at 1.5 percent is $7.20. The $25 autopay credit comes on top if you meet its conditions.
  • Discover it Secured: $120 in an activated 5 percent category earns $6, and the remaining $360 at 1 percent earns $3.60, for $9.60. With Cashback Match, that $9.60 becomes $19.20 in the first year. Without the bonus categories, the same $480 returns $4.80.

Julia would not make a $20 purchase she did not need to collect that $4.80 difference.

On the Freedom Rise budget of $240 a month, which is $2,880 a year, Freedom Rise earns $43.20. The $25 autopay credit raises that to $68.20 for the first year.

The reported balance matters more than the number of purchases:

  • Chase Freedom Rise: with a $500 limit, a reported balance of $240 is 48 percent utilization. Paying it down to $60 before the balance is reported brings that to 12 percent.
  • Discover it Secured: with a $200 limit, a reported balance of $40 is 20 percent, and $160 is 80 percent.

There is no exact percentage to chase, and you do not need to pay interest to show use.

The Freedom Rise upgrade has its own example. If $80 a month is dining, that is $960 a year, and Freedom Unlimited's 3 percent instead of 1.5 percent adds $14.40 a year. Julia counts that only once the upgrade has actually arrived.

Before you apply

For Chase Freedom Rise, check Chase's page for:

  • The current terms of the $25 autopay credit.
  • The restaurant offer for the first 6 months.
  • The conditions of the annual upgrade review.
  • If you are considering a Chase bank account, its terms, including the $250 combined balance, the 4-day window and any fees.

For Discover it Secured Cash Back, check Discover's page for:

  • The deposit amounts of $49, $99 or $200.
  • The 35-day funding window.
  • This quarter's categories, their limits and the activation step.
  • The Cashback Match terms.

Where an older description of the Discover card disagrees with your application, use the terms attached to your application or account.

If you are under 21, answer the ability-to-pay questions honestly. Independent income or assets may matter.

Terms checked October 6, 2026. Offers and approval standards may have moved since then, so confirm each figure on the issuer's page. Then pick one ordinary purchase you could reliably repay, and see whether Freedom Rise without a deposit, or Discover it Secured with one, fits your budget comfortably.

The cards in this guide

Keep reading

Terms checked Oct 6, 2026. Not financial advice.

New card tests every weekJulia tests these cards on camera, with the arithmetic on screen. Subscribe for the next one.Subscribe on YouTube