Citi Custom Cash or Blue Cash Everyday: which pays more on a family grocery bill
On the same 6,000 dollars of groceries, Custom Cash pays 300 and Blue Cash Everyday 180, but only if every billing cycle reaches 500 dollars and groceries stay on top.

The short answer
If you already hold Citi Custom Cash and your grocery bill reaches 500 dollars every billing cycle, Custom Cash pays more. Over 12 cycles, Custom Cash pays 300 dollars on those 6,000 dollars of groceries. Blue Cash Everyday pays 180 on the same 6,000 at its 3 percent supermarket rate. Neither card has an annual fee (terms checked October 6, 2026).
Custom Cash's lead depends on three conditions:
- Groceries have to stay Custom Cash's top eligible category.
- Each cycle has to reach the 500 dollar cap.
- A quiet month cannot lend its unused room to a busy one.
Blue Cash Everyday works differently. Its allowance is yearly, so the calendar does not matter. The store does matter, because Amex's supermarket category does not automatically include superstores or warehouse clubs.
Citi closed Custom Cash to new applications on May 28, 2026, and says existing cardholders are unaffected. So this comparison is for someone who already holds Custom Cash. For that person, the answer is often to keep both cards and give each one part of the grocery bill.
Side by side
All terms checked October 6, 2026.
- Annual fee: Citi Custom Cash, none. Blue Cash Everyday, none.
- Grocery rate: Citi Custom Cash pays 5 percent on your top eligible category. Blue Cash Everyday pays 3 percent at eligible U.S. supermarkets.
- Cap: Citi Custom Cash pays 5 percent on the first 500 dollars each billing cycle. That adds up to 6,000 dollars over 12 cycles only if every cycle reaches the cap. Blue Cash Everyday pays 3 percent on the first 6,000 dollars a year at supermarkets.
- Rate after the cap: Citi Custom Cash pays 1 percent. Blue Cash Everyday pays 1 percent.
- Other bonus categories: Citi Custom Cash applies its 5 percent to one category per cycle. Citi chooses it automatically from a list that includes restaurants, gas stations, grocery stores and drugstores. Blue Cash Everyday also pays 3 percent at U.S. online retailers and at U.S. gas stations, and each of those has its own 6,000 dollar yearly cap.
- Rewards: Citi Custom Cash earns ThankYou points, worth 1 cent each when redeemed for cash. Blue Cash Everyday earns Reward Dollars, and 1 Reward Dollar is a 1 dollar statement credit.
- Extra: Blue Cash Everyday has a Disney streaming credit of up to 7 dollars a month after enrollment. That comes to 84 dollars a year only if you already pay for an eligible subscription every month.
- Julia's Wallet Score: Citi Custom Cash 63 out of 100. Blue Cash Everyday 67 out of 100.
- Availability: Citi Custom Cash takes no new applications. Blue Cash Everyday is open to applicants.
The arithmetic
In Julia's family example, a household spends 750 dollars a month at a regular supermarket, which is 9,000 dollars a year. Groceries that earn no bonus go on a no-fee 2 percent card, Wells Fargo Active Cash. On its own, Active Cash earns 180 dollars on these groceries.
Blue Cash Everyday with the 2 percent card:
- The first 6,000 dollars at 3 percent earns 180.
- The remaining 3,000 dollars at 2 percent earns 60.
- The total is 240 dollars, which is 60 more than Active Cash alone.
Citi Custom Cash, at 750 dollars in each of 12 billing cycles:
- 500 dollars a cycle at 5 percent earns 25 a cycle, or 300 a year.
- The other 250 dollars a cycle comes to 3,000 dollars a year. On the 2 percent card that earns 60, for a total of 360. That is 120 more than the Blue Cash Everyday pair, which uses the same 2 percent backup.
- In Julia's worked example, the 250 goes on a 3 percent grocery card, Capital One Savor. The 3,000 dollars then earns 90, for a total of 390.
Holding both Custom Cash and Blue Cash Everyday also reaches 390, as long as the supermarket qualifies. Put 500 dollars a cycle on Custom Cash, which earns 300. The leftover 3,000 dollars fits inside Blue Cash Everyday's 6,000 dollar supermarket allowance and earns 90 at 3 percent.
What happens when the grocery bill runs past Custom Cash's cap?
Citi Custom Cash pays 5 percent only on the first 500 dollars of a cycle. Julia's rule is that Custom Cash is a 500 dollar card, not a 5 percent card.
In Julia's worked example, a 1,200 dollar grocery cycle on Custom Cash alone earns 32 dollars: 25 on the first 500 and 7 on the other 700 at 1 percent. Splitting the bill earns more on the same groceries:
- The first 500 on Custom Cash earns 25.
- The remaining 700 on a 3 percent grocery card earns 21.
- The total is 46, against 32 with the whole bill on Custom Cash.
Blue Cash Everyday can do that 3 percent job at a qualifying supermarket while its 6,000 dollar yearly allowance lasts.
An uneven year matters more on Custom Cash than on Blue Cash Everyday. Take 200 dollars a cycle for 6 cycles and 800 for the other 6, which is 6,000 dollars in all:
- Citi Custom Cash: each quiet cycle earns 10 and each busy cycle earns 28, for 228 over the year. That is 72 less than the same 6,000 spread evenly.
- Blue Cash Everyday: all 6,000 dollars sit inside the yearly supermarket cap, so the month-to-month pattern does not change the result. The total is 180 at 3 percent.
On that uneven year, Custom Cash still leads Blue Cash Everyday by 48 dollars. But Custom Cash's 300 assumes every cycle reaches the cap.
Custom Cash can also give its 5 percent to a purchase you did not intend. In Julia's food example, a cycle with 500 dollars of groceries and 400 of dining earns 29 on Custom Cash alone. Move the dining to a 2 percent card and the same cycle earns 33. Blue Cash Everyday's supermarket rate is a fixed category, so a restaurant bill cannot take its place.
Does a superstore or warehouse club count for Blue Cash Everyday?
Not automatically. Amex's supermarket category does not automatically include superstores or warehouse clubs, and buying groceries there does not change how the store is classified.
In Julia's full-year Blue Cash Everyday example, 7,200 dollars of groceries at a qualifying supermarket earns 192: 180 on the first 6,000 and 12 on the last 1,200. At a superstore outside the category, the same 7,200 dollars earns 72 at 1 percent. If your family shops mostly at a superstore or warehouse club, Blue Cash Everyday's grocery advantage disappears.
With Citi Custom Cash, check your own statement. It shows which category won each cycle and how much earned only 1 percent.
Where each one wins
Citi Custom Cash wins when one predictable grocery bill lands close to 500 dollars every billing cycle. Custom Cash also does well as one half of a pair, with a 3 percent card taking the amount past the cap. Julia's test describes Custom Cash as suited to a regular, limited job.
Blue Cash Everyday wins when your spending cycles are uneven and you shop at a qualifying U.S. supermarket. It gains more when your online purchases of goods and your fill-ups at U.S. gas stations also earn its 3 percent. It also suits you if you would use the Disney streaming credit. Blue Cash Everyday's weak spots are excluded stores and the 1 percent ordinary rate.
Holding both cards works when the supermarket qualifies. Custom Cash takes the first 500 dollars of groceries each cycle, and Blue Cash Everyday takes the rest, up to its yearly allowance.
How do the Wallet Scores compare?
Blue Cash Everyday scores 67 out of 100 on Julia's everyday card test, and Citi Custom Cash scores 63. Julia's test mostly weighs value after costs across three household budgets, then reward flexibility, effort and two protection checks. It is not a grocery-only ranking.
That is why Custom Cash can win the grocery arithmetic and still score lower. The 500 dollar cap per cycle, and the 1 percent after it, count against Custom Cash across a whole household's spending.
Before you apply
Citi Custom Cash is closed to new applicants, so this decision is about how to use a Custom Cash card you already have. The closure does not close existing accounts, and it does not guarantee an upgrade. Read any notice about your own account on its own terms.
On Amex's page for Blue Cash Everyday, check:
- which stores count as eligible U.S. supermarkets, and whether your usual store is one of them
- the 6,000 dollar supermarket cap and the 1 percent rate after it
- the current Disney streaming credit and how enrollment works
- the redemption options. Amex has announced that Reward Dollars from its U.S. consumer cash back cards can now be deposited into an American Express High Yield Savings Account. See the issuer's page for how this applies to Blue Cash Everyday.
On your latest Citi Custom Cash statement, check which category won, how much ran past 500 dollars and what earned only 1 percent. Pay these purchases in full each month, because interest can cost more than either card earns.
Terms checked October 6, 2026. Rates, caps and credits may have changed since then, so confirm them on each issuer's page.
The cards in this guide
Keep reading
- When a flat 2 percent card earns more than bonus categories, and when a pair wins
- Which cash back card pays a big family the most on groceries once the fee is out
- Citi Custom Cash vs Bank of America Customized Cash Rewards, compared on caps
- Costco Anywhere Visa or Sam's Club Mastercard: what each card adds to the same spending
Terms checked Oct 6, 2026. Not financial advice.